During
this Pandemic Lockdown, I thought, should undertake and volunteer to write/
prepare an Online teaching course on Structural Design for polytechnic students
and make brief introductory lessons on Analysis, Mechanics, Material properties
and design of structural members. When I checked online, there are already
enough such presentations on the subject.
There are dozens, perhaps scores of them, each with a particular
purpose, or scope, and some with limitations.
I withdrew from my above thoughts
and planned this blog. Philosophy of Design ( not on Design Philosophy) which I
always pondered during my learning and my function as a design engineer during my
career. I thought I should put into this
blog the results of some 40 years of my experience just the way to suit my
fancy thoughts.
To
think of such a philosophy in structural engineering design, one must think of
the principles and concepts which formulates the principles and methodology
based on material properties, and their behaviour applied though set
limitations of code of practices. In contrast, Design Philosophy is simply a
brief of your calculations and explanations of what is objective and its
boundaries or scope of a particular project design. One may ask what philosophy
got to do with engineering? Perhaps great engineers of early times also
happened to be great thinkers and philosophers. Therefore Philosophy is a
significant aspect of engineering and can also be related to one's life in
general.
In Construction, everything needs to be
designed first. Designers deal with analysis and design to ensure a safe and
economic structure. In this process, the structural engineer needs to have
knowledge of the behaviour of materials under various loading conditions and
thereby select appropriate construction material and apply fundamentals of
Reinforced Concrete and structural steel. In design, it is planning of assembly
or joining of various components put together, which will act in union effectively
against different loading conditions. The essential purpose of design is to
ensure the structure remains safe and functional under any sever condition
during its life span.
So
designers apply principles of mechanics to analyse the behaviour of every
component, thereby establishing most appropriate structural arrangement by
assuming the sizes of the members /elements on estimated loads with the given Factor
of safety. .Whereas the science of strength of materials dictates the
relationship its internal behaviour under given externally applied loads.
Thereby developed stresses on these members are catered for by using
appropriate design rules. So these structures are expected to withstand
internal pressures developed due to self-weight ( Deadweight) and superimposed
loads in various forms such as uniformly distributed, Point loads or lateral
loads such as wind and earthquake loads.
Some examples in my attempt to relate this
philosophy to human mind and behaviour that we can assume with the category of
people who are bit easy to go with are statically determinate and bit difficult
persons as Statically Indeterminate. Dead loads compared to qualities such as
personality, upbringing culture and manners.
Live loads are external influences caused by external factors. The lateral
loads are wind loads; an earthquake is related to some externally affected
problems like financial, emotional or any new problem thrust upon us. The earth
pressure and hydrostatic loads are like our depends family and friends who
influence your life regularly depending on those peoples nature and character
and their interaction with us. These qualities can be related to unit weight, cohesion,
angle of internal friction and sometimes the overburden load and the angle of
that overburden.
These above factors create stresses in our
mind and personality with tensile stress ( Mental Tension) Compression ( Happiness)
Bending stress ( Financial burden) and shear stress ( Physical turmoil or
stress like hypertension, etc.). The supports like Roller, Pined or fixed act
as your attitude toward the loads acting on us. So it essential to determine
internal forces acting on us first to understand our self-analysis and then the
external loads. So it is to realise that the application of these loads on us
leads to deformation depending on the entire loading system. So resisting these
loads create a bending moment is the Art of living. We need to learn how to develop
ourselves a sound resistant system or
mindset.
Hooke's law states that within the Elastic
limits, stress is directly proportional to strain. The Young's Modulus and
Poisson ratios are two essential properties of matter which are like a perfect
character and mindset, which will help us in dealing with problems and difficulties
in life.
I believe that the best engineers and
magnificent structures are designed and built on excellent characteristics of a
member, its material properties with the forces anticipated for the worst case
of loadings. The load types being static or dynamic, lateral or vertical which
are founded on a great foundation amid soil with a known bearing capacity or
the given design life. Adequate Factor of safety in design assumptions can make
the structure serve adequately for the purpose like a person with great character
lives and serves better to Humanity. Build to serve and serve to build.
Ever Onwards and press on regardless !!
Suresh Ramadurgakar
Comments
"A fine exposition of life, it’s complexities and solutions. Feel like reading it again. Well said Ramdurgkar"
SP
Thank you Sir
SR